I have used them all, cotton mitts, cotton gloves, silicone, leather, etc. This glove beats them all...I was skeptical by my hand stays cool when I pick things (skewers, a metal cooking grid) directly off the hot grill surface. The flexibility makes this glove the easiest to use.
We also use it in the kitchen. I highly recommend this BBQ glove
That I'm going back for another and getting them for gifts...I love to use them in the kitchen ...oven to table no problem. So much easier than mitts or hot pads. I can see where they might be small for folks with LARGE hands, but for my wife and I they are perfect. Primarily used indoors where the heat is some less than grilling, but they do work well at/around the Weber too! Word of caution, effectiveness decreases tremendously when they get wet so be careful when working around liquids