Cookie Toppings

Indulge your sweet tooth and take your cookie creations to the next level with our wide selection of delectable cookie toppings. From colorful sprinkles to rich chocolate chips, our collection has everything you need to add that perfect finishing touch to your homemade treats. Whether you're baking for a special occasion or simply want to add a pop of flavor, our cookie toppings are sure to satisfy every craving. Explore our range of options and let your imagination run wild as you create mouthwatering cookies that are as beautiful as they are delicious.

Sort by:
  • Sur La Table Autumn Blend Sprinkles
    $6.56

    Fun and festive, our autumnal sprinkle blend is the perfect topping for cocoa, baked goods and ice cream! Our blend is made from premium ingredients and adds a lovely, warm accent to your desserts.

  • Savannah Bee Company Whipped Cinnamon Honey
    $19.95
    (1166)

    Spice up your life with this unforgettable treat! This honey, sourced from the fields of Montana, is spun with organic Ceylon cinnamon from Sri Lanka to form a silky, aromatic ambrosia perfect in hot beverages and as a tasty topping for baked goods....

    Pros: taste, versatility, delicious

  • Microplane Premium Spice Grater
    $11.95
    (5)

    The circular design on this Microplane premium classic spice grater lets you easily grate just the right amount of hard spices such as nutmeg or cinnamon onto hot beverages. Non-clogging etched teeth release ultra-fine shavings of chocolate or nuts onto...

    Pros: easy to use, finer grate, effective

  • Picnic Time Parlor Ice Cream Mixing Set
    $114.95
    (3)

    Here’s the scoop: this ice cream mixing set brings the fun of the ice cream parlor right to your kitchen. This set includes ceramic dishes, stainless steel mixing spades and a beautiful marble slab, all perfectly fitted into a sturdy bamboo board. Simply...

    Pros: quality, fancy design, enjoyable for kids

  • Sur La Table Autumn Edible Glitter Blend
    $6.56
    (1)

    Fun and festive, our autumnal glitter blend is the perfect topping for cocoa, baked goods and ice cream! Our blend is made from premium ingredients and adds a sparkle-filled accent to your desserts.

    Pros: nice colors, festive touch

  • Sur La Table Demerara Sugar
    $10.95
    (1)

    Boasting a distinct molasses undertone, our demerara sugar is perfect for sweetening coffee or for adding hints of crunchy sweetness to the tops of baked goods. The grains of demerara sugar are slightly larger than granulated sugar, making it especially...

  • Sur La Table Belgian Waffle Mix
    $16.95
    (1)

    Looking for a delicious breakfast or brunch option? Look no further than our Belgian waffles! Cooked to crispy perfection, our Belgian waffles are the perfect balance of crispy exterior and fluffy interior. Enjoy them as a classic waffle with powdered...

    Pros: delicious waffles

  • Sur La Table Chocolate Crêpe Mix
    $16.95

    Plan a crêpe escape from boring breakfasts with decadent chocolate crepes that pair beautifully with fresh fruit and cream or chocolate hazelnut spread. Best filled with whipped cream or nut spread, and topped with whipped cream, chocolate shavings or...

  • Sur La Table Royal Icing Mix
    $13.95
    (1)

    Top cupcakes, donuts and more with this sweet icing mix from our home brand. To make, all you have to do is combine the mix with 4 tablespoons of water.

  • Sur La Table Red Velvet Cookie Mix
    $18.95

    Tangy, sweet and chocolatey, our red velvet cookie mix takes the popular cake and turns it into moist, delicious cookies. Try it with chocolate chips for an extra chocolatey twist. Top with cream cheese frosting for a decadent dessert that will impress...

Cookie Toppings

When it comes to cookie toppings, the possibilities are as varied as the bakers who sprinkle, drizzle, and dust them. Whether you’re baking with little ones on a rainy afternoon, prepping treats for a summer picnic, or adding a festive flourish to a holiday cookie exchange, the right toppings can transform even the simplest batch into something memorable. Think of the sparkle of sanding sugar catching the light, the satisfying crunch of chopped nuts, or the rich, velvety finish of a chocolate drizzle. Each choice adds its own texture, flavor, and visual appeal, inviting creativity and personalization. Toppings are more than just decoration—they’re an opportunity to tailor each cookie to the occasion, the season, or the tastes of your friends and family. As the days grow warmer in May, lighter and brighter flavors come into play: citrus zest, freeze-dried berries, and pastel sprinkles feel right at home on cookies destined for backyard gatherings or end-of-school celebrations.

Choosing the right cookie toppings depends on the experience you want to create. For those who love to bake with kids, colorful sprinkles and edible glitter can turn baking into an interactive art project, making memories as well as treats. If you’re hosting a cookie decorating party, set out bowls of toasted coconut, mini chocolate chips, and crushed candies so everyone can design their own masterpiece. For the seasoned baker, more nuanced toppings like flaky sea salt, spiced sugars, or candied ginger offer a way to experiment with flavor profiles and elevate classic recipes. Toppings also make thoughtful gifts—an assortment of gourmet sugars or specialty drizzles, paired with a handwritten recipe, is a welcome surprise for a fellow baking enthusiast or a teacher at the end of the school year. And when it comes to presentation, a well-chosen topping can turn a humble cookie into a centerpiece, perfect for gifting or sharing.

No matter your skill level or baking style, having a variety of toppings on hand opens up endless possibilities. They’re the finishing touch that can save a slightly overbaked batch, add excitement to a familiar recipe, or help you celebrate a special moment. For those looking to expand their baking repertoire, exploring new textures and flavors is as simple as reaching for something different from your pantry shelf. If you’re ready to stock up or discover something new, you’ll find a wide array of options in our curated collection of Cookie Supplies. With the right toppings at your fingertips, every batch becomes a canvas, and every cookie tells its own delicious story.

FAQ List

Best Sellers

Related Pages

  •
    Unique Cookies

    "The cookies were delicious"

  •
    Cookie Supplies

    "Just what I needed to prepare meals in the oven or just bake cookies for my guests, these baking sheets are wonderful and very easy to clean and store"

  •
    Popular Cookies

    "Never used a cookie scoop before - why did I wait so long! This is ideal for getting those uniform cookie sizes"

  •
    Waffle Toppings

    "Whether you enjoy it on a biscuit as part of your breakfast meal or as a sweetener you have as topping for a desert. My wife likes to add it to her hot tea"

  •
    Cookie Baking Tools

    "It truly makes a difference in the cooking outcome. I look forward to baking cookies on it"

Top Collections