Toasters For Thick Bagels

Toasters for thick bagels are designed to handle hearty slices and generously sized bagels with ease. Whether you prefer a classic bagel breakfast or enjoy artisan breads, these toasters offer the space and versatility needed for a satisfying toast every time. Find options that make it simple to enjoy your favorite thick-cut baked goods at home.

Sort by:
  • Zwilling Enfinigy 4-Slot Toaster
    $200
    (1255)

    Bagel burn...I had tried other toasters that burned my bagels or got stuck in toaster. ...Bagel toaster....Does exactly what I need. I have bagels every day and this toaster, toasts them perfectly.

    Pros: even toasting, sleek design, appearance

  • Cuisinart Toaster, 2 Slice
    $79.95
    (563)

    Nice toaster...Nice toaster. Toasts well. Have always had Cuisinart toasters....Replaced a 10 year old 2 slice toaster. The 4 wide slots allow for thick slices of bread and bagels to be easily toasted.

    Pros: versatility, compact size, attractive design

  • Cuisinart Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster
    $79.95
    (484)

    Four-Slice Toaster...My only disappointment was to discover that the "Bagel" cycle on this toaster does not limit the toasting to one side of the bagel, as has been the case with my past toasters (and expected). ...Best toaster for bagels!...This is...

    Pros: even toasting, convenient, easy to clean

  • Café™ Express Finish Toaster
    $98.96
    (462)

    Cafe Toaster...This is the best toaster I have ever owned. Toasts bread and bagels (even frozen) perfectly everytime....Awesome toaster! Toasts evenly. Very happy with it. Better than other more expensive toasters.

    Pros: appearance, even toasting, aesthetic design

  • Zwilling Enfinigy 2-Slot Toaster
    $140
    (187)

    Everything is better then the old toaster. Toast both sides evenly, bagel is nice, cool touch, and bread comes up when it's done....Beautiful Toaster...Slots are wide to accommodate bagels and thick cut loaves. Love it. ??

    Pros: sleek design, even toasting, crumb tray

  • Breville Die-Cast Toaster, 4-Slice
    $249.95
    (140)

    Bagel Buddies...Wife and I can have our bagels at the same time....Bagel Toaster Extroardinaire...Love this toaster. Bought it because toast a lot of bagels, and it's the best.

    Pros: durable, reliable, features

  • Krups Breakfast Set 2-Slice Toaster
    $64.95
    (36)

    We have tried several toasters but they only toasted half the bread. I love this toaster- bagels, sourdough bread, muffins etc all toast perfectly!...Great toaster...Really like it, multiple settings, wide enough for bagels and a bagel setting. Glad...

    Pros: toasts evenly, works great, lightweight

  • Breville Toast Select Luxe
    $219.95
    (21)

    We are really disappointed because we love this toaster!...This toaster is worth it!...I was hesitant to spend the $'s, but glad I did. The toaster dials in to the perfect piece of toast when different family members like darker or lighter.

    Pros: adjustable toasting, produces nice results, love toaster

  • Zwilling Enfinigy 2-Slot Long Toaster
    $200
    (524)

    Solid Toaster...Great toaster. Toasts well. Handle thick bagels. No issues...STYLISH TOASTER...This toaster is amazing and one of the most practical toasters we have used for bread slices and bagels

    Pros: even toasting, sleek design, performance

  • Breville A-Bit-More 2-Slice Toaster
    $109.95
    (229)

    Bagel Perfect...I am bagel lover so the most important thing for me is that my thick New York Style bagels fit easily in the slots when split. ...Nice toaster...Really happy with this toaster. It cost a little more than some other toasters but feels...

    Pros: even toasting, 'a bit more' feature, bagel setting

  • Breville Die-Cast Smart Toaster
    $219.95
    (198)

    Perfect Toaster...I absolutely love this toaster. Fits different size breads and bagels. Perfect!...Great Toaster. Long lasting. Excellent for bagels & look-and-see pop-up optoin....Great toaster for bagels as the bagel button widens the gap.

    Pros: brand reputation, bagel setting, durable

  • Breville A-Bit-More 4-Slice Toaster
    $119.95
    (193)

    Great toaster...The frozen settings for bagels not bad. Even so I've had many toasters and thus one is still the best!...Five Star Toaster!...The ultimate toaster! I don?t know how we have lived without a toaster this good.

    Pros: even toasting, wide slots, quality

  • Breville Die-Cast 2-Slice Smart Toaster
    $199.95
    (181)

    I finally retired my 30 year old cop of the line toaster. I could not believe the difference. This toasts bread, thick bread, bagels, and hamburger buns reliably....A great toaster with the features it offers; thin and thick bread, bagels, "A Bit More",...

    Pros: durable, perfect toast, appearance

Toasters For Thick Bagels

There’s something undeniably satisfying about a perfectly toasted bagel—golden and crisp on the outside, warm and pillowy on the inside, with just enough room for a generous layer of cream cheese or a swipe of butter that melts into every crevice. For those who savor thick, bakery-style bagels or prefer artisan breads with hearty crusts, a standard toaster just won’t cut it. That’s where toasters designed for thick bagels come in, offering extra-wide slots and specialized settings that deliver even browning without crushing the delicate texture of your favorite breakfast treat. These toasters are more than just kitchen appliances—they’re an invitation to slow down and enjoy the little rituals that make mornings special, whether you’re fueling up for a busy workday or gathering around the table for a leisurely weekend brunch.

Choosing the right toaster for thick bagels involves more than just slot size, though that’s certainly a top priority. Look for features like adjustable browning controls, bagel-specific settings that toast the cut side while gently warming the outside, and high-lift levers that make it easy to retrieve smaller slices without risking burnt fingertips. Removable crumb trays simplify cleanup, while sturdy construction and intuitive controls make daily use a pleasure. These thoughtful touches are especially appreciated in households where breakfast is a family affair or in kitchens where counter space is at a premium and every appliance needs to earn its keep. Toasters for thick bagels also make thoughtful gifts for recent graduates setting up their first apartments, newlyweds outfitting a shared kitchen, or anyone who delights in a well-prepared breakfast. They’re a practical upgrade that transforms a simple meal into a moment worth savoring.

As summer sets in and the days grow longer, there’s a renewed joy in gathering for breakfast on the patio or indulging in a toasted bagel with seasonal fruit before heading out for the day. A quality toaster designed for thick bagels can elevate these everyday moments, ensuring that every slice—whether it’s a seeded everything bagel, a sweet cinnamon raisin, or a crusty artisan loaf—emerges perfectly toasted and ready for your favorite toppings. If you’re looking to explore even more options for your kitchen, from classic two-slice models to larger styles that handle a variety of breads, visit Toasters For Bagels And Breads for a curated selection that brings café-quality results to your countertop. With the right toaster, you can celebrate the simple pleasure of a great bagel—any day of the week.

Top Picks For Toasters For Thick Bagels


Best Sellers

Related Pages

  •
    Wide Slot Toasters

    "It has wide slots for bagels and other features which we have not yet tried but intend to in time"

  •
    Digital Toasters

    "Awesome toaster! Toasts evenly. Very happy with it. Better than other more expensive toasters"

  •
    Fancy Toasters

    "This is one of the nicest looking toasters on the market. It does not get very hot on the outside wish it toasts, which is good"

  •
    Smart Toasters

    "Thank you Breville, and thank you to my Smart (and sensible) Die Cast Toaster. Breakfast has been served"

  •
    Kitchen Toaster

    "We replaced our 10+ year old Cuisinart toaster with a new Cuisinart toaster that is an even better toaster than its predecessor"

Top Collections