Cookie Making Supplies

Get ready to whip up some delicious homemade cookies with this wide selection of cookie-making supplies. Whether you're a seasoned baker or just starting out, we have everything you need to create the perfect batch of cookies. From high-quality baking sheets and non-stick silicone mats to a variety of cookie cutters in different shapes and sizes, these supplies will inspire your creativity in the kitchen. With this range of mixing bowls, measuring cups, and spoons, precise measurements are a breeze.

Sort by:
  • OXO Cookie Press with Storage Box
    $40
    (48)

    Beautiful Cookies...Used the recipe in the box and cookie dough was getting stuck. When it was dispensing properly it was making beautiful cookies. ...I love this cookie press!...I absolutely love this cookie press! Its very easy and fun to use, so much...

    Pros: works well, ease of use, sharp metal dies

  • OXO Good Grips Cookie Dough Scoop, Small
    $17.95
    (45)

    I don't make cookies without this...I get a uniform shape which gives my baking a very professional appearance, especially when making sandwich cookies or ice cream sandwiches....Cookie size is consistent and all the cookies on the tray bake up the same...

    Pros: ease of use, durable, easy to clean

  • Silpat Cookie Sheet Baking Mat
    $29.95
    (21)

    A mainstay of many bakers, this nonstick silicone mat by Silpat has the ideal surface to bake up sticky doughs, gooey batters and other sweet treats. Constructed from durable food-grade silicone and reinforced with a flexible glass weave, it promotes...

    Pros: versatile, easy cleanup, non-stick

  • Silpat Half Sheet Baking Mat
    $29.95
    (19)

    Makes baking cookies a dream. Cookie sheet stays clean, easy to remove cookies. ...EASY cleaning. Made our choc chip cookies perfect!

    Pros: non-stick, easy to clean, works great

  • Silpat 3/4 Size Baking Mat, Silicone
    $38.95
    (11)

    When you love your Silpat mats and buy larger cookie sheets......Just love these mats!!!! Love them for making cookies

    Pros: easy to clean, love, good for lining baking pans

  • Sur La Table Stainless Steel Fluted Biscuit Cutters, Set of 5
    $27.95
    (10)

    "Great for Biscuits, Cookies or Tarts"...I bought mine for biscuits, but used them for making holiday tarts and cookies as well. Every baker in your family should have a set...I love my biscuit cutters, I can use for cookies also.

    Pros: sturdy, versatility, well made

  • Sur La Table Round Cookie Cutters, Set of 10
    $19.95
    (2)

    Cookie cutters

    Pros: storage tin, variety of sizes

  • OXO 3-Piece Cookie Scoop Set
    $29.95
    (1)

    My favorite cookie tool!...Love these! They make cookie making even more fun and easy!

    Pros: easy to use, fun

  • Sur La Table Round Copper-Plated Cookie Cutter, 2.5"
    $6
    (1)

    Create perfectly round cookies with our durable cookie cutter. Thanks to the elegant copper plating, this cookie cutter is more resistant to tarnishing and regular wear and tear, meaning it can withstand plenty of use. Ideal for gift giving, crafting...

    Pros: perfect size

  • Sur La Table Heart Cookie Cutters, Set of 6
    $19.95
    (1)

    Grow your baking collection with this set of six heart-shaped cookie cutters. Perfect for baking cute cookies, biscuits and other tasty treats for Valentine's Day or special occasions. Made of stainless steel for durability through cut after cut. Set...

    Pros: dishwasher safe

  • Cuisinart Stand Mixer, 5.5 qt.
    $319.95
    (733)

    I can't wait to get the attachments for it to grind meat and make pasta....Purchased 1When my Mixer died while making cookies. Delighted with my new mixer

    Pros: powerful, price, ease of use

  • Sur La Table Platinum Pro Jelly Roll Pan, 14.25" x 9.37"
    $31.96
    (35)

    Cookie sheets...I had bought an entire set of cake pans, loaf pans and cookie sheets made of this USA brand and loved them.

    Pros: easy to clean, non-stick, durable

  • Norpro Deluxe Pastry and Pizza Roller
    $17.95
    (11)

    Easily create perfectly smooth dough for pies, cookies, pizzas and more with this handy tool. The large roller is perfect for the initial rolling, while the smaller roller makes it easy to smooth uneven spots, push dough to the pan edges and ensure a...

    Pros: handy, versatile, space-saving

  • Sur La Table Marble Pastry Board
    $99.95
    (9)

    Perfect for candy making...I was having a hard time making old fashioned fudge until I got this marble slab to pour out on. ...Love it for making noodles, cookie dough, and bread dough!

    Pros: great size, ease of rolling pastries and doughs, aesthetic value

  • Sur La Table Silicone Measuring Cups, Set of 3
    $29.95
    (6)

    Gosh, can anyone have too many shoes, purses or baking supplies? These are great. As soon as they go on sale I'm getting another set!

    Pros: stackable, child proof, dishwasher safe

  • Sur La Table Signature 3/4 Sheet Pan
    $31.96
    (5)

    I also loved how versatile this pan is; it's great for roasting vegetables or baking cookies, making it a valuable addition to my kitchen....This large capacity tray is perfect for holiday baking! With cookie season approaching quickly, this pan can...

    Pros: nonstick, versatile, easy cleanup

  • Sur La Table Lemon Meyer Cookie Mix
    $19.95
    (4)

    Easy to make and delicious. Great texture and wonderful lemon flavor....the cookies do not taste the same. they are now too much lemon flavor

    Pros: customization, taste, easy to make

  • Sur La Table Offset Icing Spatula
    $15.86
    (4)

    Great tool for small cookies or detail in icing cookies and cupcakes.

    Pros: easy to use, early arrival, well packaged

  • Sur La Table Sapphire Elite Half-Sheet Pans, Set of 2
    $71.96
    (3)

    Bake cookies, sheet pan meals and more with our durable half sheet pans. Made from aluminized steel, these pans heat evenly for great results on your favorite dishes.

    Designed to exceed the expectations of even the most demanding professional bakers,...

    Pros: dishwasher safe, price, no rust

  • Sur La Table 15-Piece Cupcake Decorating Set
    $13.66
    (1)

    Decorate cupcakes, cookies and treats with this set of basic tools that let you create stars, rosettes, shells dots and more. Perfect for all ages and reusable, this kit makes it easy to decorate your baked goods.

    Pros: good price, adequate features

  • Delight Patisserie Uniquely You Cookie Box
    $36.95
    (1)

    These cookies were really good because they were not sweet and did not contain a lot of sugar.

    Pros: buttery taste, low sugar, not sweet

  • Sur La Table Pie Linzer Cookie Cutters, Set of 4
    $15.96
    (1)

    Versatile - for cookies, hand pies, and mini pies...I am glad to have these, which are a great size not just for cookies but also small hand pies or top crusts. They are very well made and easy to use.

    Pros: great size, easy to use, cute

  • PME Bold Colored Edible Ink Pens, Set of 5
    $11.95
    (1)

    Just what I needed for Baseball ?? cookies. It turned out great and it was so easy and fast to draw.

    Pros: ease of use, suitability for drawing, speed

  • Nordic Ware Naturals Large Classic Cookie Sheet
    $24.95

    Get delicious results every time on homemade cookies with this cookie sheet from Nordic Ware Naturals. Made from cast aluminum, this cookie sheet heats evenly, and thanks to the raised edges, this sheet is easy to grasp with oven mitts.

Cookie Making Supplies

Creating homemade cookies is a tradition that brings people together, whether it’s a quiet afternoon in the kitchen or a lively gathering with friends and family. The right cookie making supplies can transform the baking process into something truly enjoyable, making it easy to craft everything from classic chocolate chip cookies to intricate holiday shapes. When selecting materials for baking cookies, it’s important to consider not just the basics like mixing bowls and spatulas, but also specialized tools that add efficiency and precision. For instance, a sturdy baking sheet ensures even browning, while a cooling rack helps cookies set perfectly once out of the oven. If you’re looking to make uniform treats, a Sur La Table cookie scoop can be a game-changer, allowing you to portion dough quickly and consistently for professional-looking results every time. Silicone baking mats and parchment paper liners are also invaluable for preventing sticking and simplifying cleanup, making them must-haves for anyone who bakes regularly.

Cookie supplies aren’t just for experienced bakers; they’re also ideal for beginners or anyone looking to start a new hobby. With summer in full swing, now is a great time to experiment with new recipes, perhaps involving seasonal fruits or light, citrusy flavors that capture the essence of June. Kids can get involved with decorating, using piping bags and colorful sprinkles to add their own creative touch. For those who enjoy gifting, a thoughtfully assembled set of cookie making supplies makes a memorable present for housewarmings, weddings, or birthdays—especially when paired with a handwritten recipe card or a jar of homemade cookie mix. A Sur La Table cookie press is perfect for anyone who loves adding a decorative flourish, making it easy to create beautiful, detailed cookies that look as good as they taste. Whether you’re baking for a special occasion or simply enjoying a quiet moment at home, having the right tools on hand can elevate the entire experience, turning a simple batch of cookies into a cherished memory.

Shopping for cookie supplies is about more than just checking items off a list; it’s about finding pieces that fit your style and make baking feel effortless. Look for durable materials that can withstand repeated use, and consider how each tool will fit into your kitchen routine. Nonstick surfaces, ergonomic handles, and dishwasher-safe designs all contribute to a smoother process, so you can spend less time cleaning and more time savoring your creations. If you’re ready to explore a wider range of options or want to expand your collection, you’ll find a curated selection of essentials and unique finds on our Cookie Baking Tools page. With the right cookie making supplies, every baking session becomes an opportunity to create, share, and enjoy something delicious.

FAQ List

Best Sellers

Related Pages

Top Collections