Thanksgiving Pie Baking Dishes

Thanksgiving pie baking dishes are essential for creating classic holiday desserts like pumpkin, pecan, and apple pie. Designed to help you achieve evenly baked crusts and beautiful presentations, these dishes make it easy to serve up your favorite recipes. Whether you’re preparing a traditional family favorite or trying something new, the right Thanksgiving pie baking dish ensures your pies come out just right for your holiday celebration.

Sort by:
  • Emile Henry Modern Classics Rouge Pie Dish
    $49.96
    (131)

    Great for pies. Beautiful presentation ...Love these pie dishes. Have 6...Pie Dish...This is really good for deep dish pies.

    Pros: easy to clean, versatility, beautiful

  • Staub Stoneware Pie Dish, 9¼"
    $49.95
    (126)

    Perfect for all your pie needs. I personally bake apple pies and they always come out perfect with this dish....Beautiful pie dish...Love this beautiful pie dish. Wonderful, heavy ceramic. Pretty look for displaying pies.

    Pros: easy to clean, dishwasher safe, even cooking

  • Sur La Table Pie Dish, 9.5"
    $24.96
    (36)

    It?s deep-dish enough, despite it not being labeled as such. ...Great Affordable Pie Dish...I received this pie dish as a bonus from taking a pie baking class.

    Pros: quality, reliable, beautiful

  • Emile Henry Pie Dish, Flour
    $49.96
    (32)

    I love my Emile Henry pie dish in the RED and my brandy pecan pie was a show stopper! ...Wonderful pie baker...I have used this pie dish to bake chicken pies and various fruit pies.

    Pros: versatility, quality, durability

  • Emile Henry Ruffled Pie Dish
    $49.96
    (30)

    Love this pie dish!...Thanksgiving was even more special with this fancy pie dish....Ruffled pie dish...Excellent! I won?t make pies in anything other than the Emile Henry pie dishes.

    Pros: appearance, easy to clean, beautiful design

  • Sur La Table Platinum Pro Pie Dish, 9"
    $27.95
    (18)

    Large pot pie...I was using flimsy thin aluminum frozen pie pans reused to make 9" chicken or beef pot pies with pie crust...I used my new pie pan to bake our Thanksgiving pie . The pan worked great,the crust was golden and delicious .

    Pros: heavy, even heat distribution, sturdy

  • Le Creuset Heritage Tarte Tatin Dish, 2 qt.
    $174.95
    (5)

    I can make my caramel on the gas stove top and then add my apples and pie crust dough and put it in the oven to bake. ...I suggest baking pies in a convection oven.. My oven is gas but it fit perfectly in my small inexpensive countertop convection toaster...

    Pros: easy to clean, presentation, works well for tarte tatin

  • Sur La Table Glass Pie Dish, 9"
    $21.95
    (1)

    Sur La Table pie plates...Perfect for a smaller quiche or pie. Thumbs up! ??

    Pros: depth, size, simplicity

  • Le Creuset Heritage Pie Dish, 9"
    $55.95

    Perfect for sweet or savory pies, quiche and more, this beautiful Le Creuset Heritage Pie Dish provides gentle, even heating for excellent results every time. Making an evenly fluted crust is easy thanks to the dimpled edge, and the thick enamel resists...

    Pros: depth, quality, beautiful color

  • Le Creuset Heritage 2-Piece Fluted Pie Dish Set, 9"
    $79.96

    Create brilliantly baked pies, quiches, pot pies, casseroles and more with this set of beautiful Le Creuset Heritage Pie Dishes. Crafted from premium stoneware, the exceptionally even heat distribution produces uniform golden-brown flaky crusts and perfectly...

  • Le Creuset Heritage Fluted Pie Dish & Loaf Pan Set
    $79.96

    Make your baked goods using this beautiful bakeware from Le Creuset. Made from thick enamel, this pan resists scratching and will stay beautiful for years to come. Durable stoneware features an industry-leading enamel interior that protects against utensil...

  • Staub Stoneware 3-Piece Rectangular Baker Set
    $99.96
    (687)

    Baking and Beauty...I highly recommend these baking dishes....Staub Cherry Baking Dishes are great!...Gorgeous baking dishes, made of high quality and seem like they will last a really long time.

    Pros: easy to clean, durable, easy cleanup

  • Staub Stoneware 2-Piece Rectangular Baker Set
    $59.96
    (506)

    Rectangular baking dishes...We love the baking dishes. Perfect for chicken pot pie and meatloaf recipes...Perfect Dishes...Beautiful dishes. Easy to clean. Perfect dish to bake

    Pros: easy to clean, durable, versatility

  • Staub Stoneware 4-Piece Baking Dish Set
    $169.96
    (363)

    Staub Dish Set...Love the dish with matching lid. The baking dishes are a little smaller than expected, but perfect for sides when hosting! ...Beautiful dark blue mixed baking dish set. The square dish with lid is especially wonderful and practical....

    Pros: durable, color, versatility

  • Staub Stoneware 2-Piece Oval Baker Set
    $59.96
    (358)

    Great baking dish...These baking dishes are great. Cooked and heated food evenly. ...staub roasting dishes...gorgeous set of baking dishes

    Pros: quality, versatility, easy to clean

  • Sur La Table Porcelain Rectangular Baker
    $79.95
    (96)

    Love this baking dish!...Versatile baker! I use it for side dishes, leftovers, and my famous baked chicken. Gave one to each daughter as well. ...I Love this Baking dish!...This is a beautiful and perfectly sized baking dish! I love it!

    Pros: easy to clean, beautiful, perfect size

  • Staub Rustic Stoneware Baker, Ivory
    $49.95
    (55)

    Perfect Baking Dish...I decided to try a ceramic baking dish and this is now my favorite 13 X 9 pan. ...Beautiful baking dishes...We received this dish along with the two smaller rectangular baking dishes set as a gift for our wedding and it has come...

    Pros: easy to clean, beautiful, durable

  • Sur La Table Rectangular Stoneware Casserole with Lid, 4 qt.
    $89.95
    (42)

    Best dish ever...Great casserole baking dish...Love the new dish The lid helps keep the food warm.

    Pros: quality, color, perfect size

  • Staub Black Baker, 3¼ qt.
    $259.95
    (42)

    My favorite baking dish!!...My favorite baking dish...tops all the others!! Cleans up easily with just an overnight soak even with the most carmelized dishes. ...Roasting Pan for Thanksgiving...We purchased the product to cook our turkey for Thanksgiving...

    Pros: versatility, easy to clean, heat retention

  • Sur La Table Stoneware 2-Piece Rectangular Baker Set
    $69.95
    (40)

    Requirement for Thanksgiving!...Excellent quality baking dishes, great sizes, very versatile.

    Pros: appearance, easy to clean, quality

  • Le Creuset Heritage Covered Baker, 4 qt.
    $134.95
    (38)

    Love the color and they're perfect for every dish...I love this baking dish. I have several nice baking dishes, but none with a nice lid like this one has.

    Pros: color, beautiful, durable

  • Emile Henry Modern Classics Mini Pie Dishes, Set of 2
    $39.96
    (33)

    The Perfect Pie Dish...I started with a regular sized pie plate 25 years ago and "graduated" to baking dishes and mini pie dishes. ...Great green colored individual pie dish...Another great green color for individual pie dishes. Colors can be associated...

    Pros: perfect size, color, easy cleanup

  • Hestan Provisions OvenBond Tri-Ply Rectangular Baker, 9" x 13"
    $120
    (26)

    Great baking dish...Use a little layer of flour and butter on a gorgeous stainless steel baking dish and you get the benefits of nonstick without the potential health hazards.

    Pros: easy to clean, beautiful, sturdy

  • Staub Pastel Macaron Stoneware 2-Piece Rectangular Baker Set
    $59.96
    (23)

    Beautiful baking dish set....Beautiful baking dish set. Colors are as expected. Recommend....Perfect Baking Dish...Great baking dishes! Sturdy and look great! Perfect for baking anything.

    Pros: color, sturdy, beautiful

Thanksgiving Pie Baking Dishes

Thanksgiving pie baking dishes are more than just vessels for your favorite holiday desserts—they’re the foundation of a cherished tradition that brings people together around the table. Whether you’re an experienced baker preparing a classic pumpkin pie from scratch or a first-time host looking to impress with a lattice-topped apple creation, choosing the right pie dish is essential. The material of your dish—ceramic, glass, or metal—can influence everything from the crispness of your crust to the evenness of the bake. Ceramic dishes hold heat well, keeping pies warm at the table and offering a beautiful presentation straight from oven to buffet. Glass options let you monitor browning for perfect results, while metal pans heat quickly and are ideal for flaky, golden crusts. Size is another important factor; a deep-dish pan is perfect for fruit pies brimming with filling, while standard sizes are versatile enough for everything from pecan to sweet potato. Many bakers appreciate fluted or ruffled edges for creating decorative crusts that look as good as they taste.

These dishes aren’t just for the holiday season. In fact, summer is an ideal time to explore pie baking, taking advantage of fresh berries, peaches, and plums in anticipation of the flavors you’ll want to recreate come November. Practicing now means you’ll be ready to wow your guests when Thanksgiving arrives. Pie baking dishes also make thoughtful gifts for anyone who loves to bake or entertain. They’re a practical present for newlyweds, housewarmings, or anyone building a kitchen collection. The right dish can inspire creativity, turning a simple recipe into a showstopper. Gifting a pie dish, especially when paired with a handwritten recipe or a set of pie weights, is a personal gesture that encourages connection and tradition. And for those who appreciate contemporary design, there are many options that blend classic function with modern style—explore the latest in Modern Pie Dishes to find pieces that complement any kitchen décor.

When selecting a Thanksgiving pie baking dish, consider how you’ll use it beyond the holiday. Many dishes are versatile enough for quiches, tarts, or savory pot pies, making them a year-round staple. Look for features like easy-grip handles, nonstick interiors, or oven-to-table designs that make serving effortless. The weight and durability of a dish can also impact your experience, especially if you plan to transport your pie to a family gathering or potluck. A well-chosen pie dish becomes a trusted companion in the kitchen, helping you create memories with every bake. Whether you’re perfecting your grandmother’s recipe or experimenting with new flavors, the right dish supports your efforts and elevates your results, making every slice a celebration.

Top Picks For Thanksgiving Pie Baking Dishes


Best Sellers

Related Pages

  •
    Modern Pie Dishes

    "Very nice pie dish. Sturdy and beautiful color"

  •
    Pie Dishes For Pot Pies

    "It makes beautiful gumbo and pot roast and the non-stick coating is easy enough to maintain"

  •
    Pie Pans

    "Bright color, solid finish and works perfectly for pies. Easy cleaning ceramic"

  •
    Ceramic Pie Dish

    "I have used the dish to make lasagna...it came out great! The dish cleans up beautifully, after soaking in warm water, dish soap"

  •
    Oven Pie Dishes

    "I was using flimsy thin aluminum frozen pie pans reused to make 9" chicken or beef pot pies with pie crust"

Top Collections