Thanksgiving Pie Baking Dishes

Thanksgiving pie baking dishes are essential for creating classic holiday desserts like pumpkin, pecan, and apple pie. Designed to help you achieve evenly baked crusts and beautiful presentations, these dishes make it easy to serve up your favorite recipes. Whether you’re preparing a traditional family favorite or trying something new, the right Thanksgiving pie baking dish ensures your pies come out just right for your holiday celebration.

Sort by:
  • Emile Henry Modern Classics Pie Dish, 9"
    $49.96
    (139)

    This is one of the best brands in ceramic. Cleans up quickly, top quality, great price...I love them. They look great and are fun to bake with.

    Pros: beautiful, easy to clean, versatility

  • Staub Stoneware Pie Dish, 9¼"
    $49.95
    (129)

    Ceramic is the best...I just love that it has handles, very ergonomically made....Staub ceramic cookware is one of the best out there. It cooks evenly, clean up is easy and it?...Get the best you can afford. Staub is that for me.

    Pros: easy to clean, dishwasher safe, even cooking

  • Sur La Table Pie Dish, 9.5"
    $24.96
    (38)

    The Best...Love this pie dish. Am always happy with my Sur La Table purchases..and they have been many!...Also great customer service and quick shipping....Heavy bakeware, even cooking and looks great!

    Pros: quality, reliable, beautiful

  • Emile Henry 9" Pie Dish
    $49.96
    (32)

    The best!...Best pie dish I?ve ever had! Everything cooks evenly and comes out perfect every time....pieces to give as Christmas presents because I want to share these incredible baking dishes with my best...I'm madly in love with this brand, and their...

    Pros: versatility, quality, durability

  • Emile Henry Ruffled Pie Dish
    $49.96
    (30)

    Great deep pie pan...Great presentation, looks gorgeous on the table....We've had ours for a few years and it always gets compliments. :) Emile Henry bakeware is the best....The best!

    Pros: appearance, easy to clean, beautiful design

  • Sur La Table Platinum Pro Pie Dish, 9"
    $22.36
    (19)

    Best toaster-oven nonstick pan!...great quality

    Pros: heavy, quality, even heat distribution

  • Le Creuset Heritage Tarte Tatin Dish, 2 qt.
    $174.95
    (5)

    So pretty and great for making fish and taking it right to the table. Also very easy to clean. I?...Love it!...Best pan in my kitchen!

    Pros: easy to clean, presentation, works well for tarte tatin

  • Sur La Table Glass Pie Dish, 9"
    $17.56
    (2)

    Love the size and depth and simplicity of these. Perfect for a smaller quiche or pie. Thumbs up!

    Pros: depth, appearance, size

  • Le Creuset Heritage 2-Piece Fluted Pie Dish Set, 9"
    $79.96

    Create brilliantly baked pies, quiches, pot pies, casseroles and more with this set of beautiful Le Creuset Heritage Pie Dishes. Crafted from premium stoneware, the exceptionally even heat distribution produces uniform golden-brown flaky crusts and perfectly...

  • Le Creuset Heritage Pie Dish, 9"
    $55.95

    Perfect for sweet or savory pies, quiche and more, this beautiful Le Creuset Heritage Pie Dish provides gentle, even heating for excellent results every time. Making an evenly fluted crust is easy thanks to the dimpled edge, and the thick enamel resists...

    Pros: depth, quality, beautiful color

  • Le Creuset Heritage Fluted Pie Dish & Loaf Pan Set
    $79.96

    Make your baked goods using this beautiful bakeware from Le Creuset. Made from thick enamel, this pan resists scratching and will stay beautiful for years to come. Durable stoneware features an industry-leading enamel interior that protects against utensil...

  • Staub Stoneware 3-Piece Rectangular Baker Set
    $99.96
    (697)

    Best pans ever...I love these casserole dishes. They cook evenly and are beautiful to boot....Love this set. It is so versatile and great for a table serving set.

    Pros: easy to clean, durable, easy cleanup

  • Staub Stoneware 2-Piece Rectangular Baker Set
    $59.96
    (560)

    These are great!...Staub is the best! Nothing sticks to these, and they are the perfect size for two people....We love them!...Great quality, if a bit small...Great quality. Beautiful color.

    Pros: durable, easy to clean, versatility

  • Staub Stoneware 4-Piece Baking Dish Set
    $99.96
    (372)

    Great dish set and a stunning look at any table. One of my best holiday gifts....Great Find...I love the quality of the four piece set; cooks perfectly like all of my other stain products and clean-up...Loved these so much I bought them for the best...

    Pros: durable, color, quality

  • Staub Stoneware 2-Piece Oval Baker Set
    $59.96
    (356)

    Bakers are Best...Love the different sizes and the color. Big is great for hosting, small is great for just two of us....Love the set it will make a great addition to our bakeware and can?t wait to use it

    Pros: quality, versatility, easy to clean

  • Sur La Table Porcelain Rectangular Baker
    $79.95
    (97)

    I love these Porcelain bakers! I have two sizes and they are the best....I love the design with the large handles on each side....Great! Does the job....I love this baker pan. Looks great and does the job.

    Pros: easy to clean, beautiful, perfect size

  • Le Creuset Heritage Covered Baker, 4 qt.
    $134.95
    (45)

    Love it! Great color. Nice handles....Love this - plus it cleans up great. Definitely recommend it.

    Pros: color, beautiful, durable

  • Sur La Table Rectangular Stoneware Casserole with Lid, 4 qt.
    $89.95
    (42)

    Best dish ever...Great casserole baking dish...Love the new dish The lid helps keep the food warm.

    Pros: quality, color, perfect size

  • Staub Black Baker
    $259.95
    (42)

    Great Heat and Size...Love the weight of this for a multipurpose and roasting....I love this pan for braising or roasting meats. It retains heat so well that it cooks so evenly....Great for the holiday season or as a one pan meal option.

    Pros: versatility, easy to clean, heat retention

  • Sur La Table Stoneware 2-Piece Rectangular Baker Set
    $69.95
    (41)

    Love these in blue! Look great on the table....Great looking product.

    Pros: appearance, easy to clean, quality

  • Hestan Provisions OvenBond Tri-Ply Rectangular Baker, 9" x 13"
    $120
    (37)

    This is by far the best quality cookware product I have ever bought. Heavy duty and even heating!...The BEST Ovenware I have Ever Used!...This is by far the best ovenware I've used!

    Pros: easy to clean, quality, sturdy

  • Emile Henry Modern Classics Mini Pie Dishes, Set of 2
    $39.96
    (34)

    Great individual Pie Dishes love the red color...Emile Henri products are a cook's best friend!...I love the ease with which they clean and the colors are bright and cheerful.

    Pros: perfect size, color, easy cleanup

  • Staub Pastel Macaron Stoneware 2-Piece Rectangular Baker Set
    $59.96
    (23)

    Love it...Great looking and perfectly practical - would recommend for sure...Great!...It bakes items so nicely and is truly great quality!

    Pros: color, beautiful, sturdiness

  • Le Creuset Heritage Square Baker, 9"
    $55.95
    (17)

    Great piece fast delivery...Great size dish

    Pros: durability, versatility, beautiful

Thanksgiving Pie Baking Dishes

Thanksgiving pie baking dishes are more than just vessels for your favorite holiday desserts—they’re the foundation of a cherished tradition that brings people together around the table. Whether you’re an experienced baker preparing a classic pumpkin pie from scratch or a first-time host looking to impress with a lattice-topped apple creation, choosing the right pie dish is essential. The material of your dish—ceramic, glass, or metal—can influence everything from the crispness of your crust to the evenness of the bake. Ceramic dishes hold heat well, keeping pies warm at the table and offering a beautiful presentation straight from oven to buffet. Glass options let you monitor browning for perfect results, while metal pans heat quickly and are ideal for flaky, golden crusts. Size is another important factor; a deep-dish pan is perfect for fruit pies brimming with filling, while standard sizes are versatile enough for everything from pecan to sweet potato. Many bakers appreciate fluted or ruffled edges for creating decorative crusts that look as good as they taste.

These dishes aren’t just for the holiday season. In fact, summer is an ideal time to explore pie baking, taking advantage of fresh berries, peaches, and plums in anticipation of the flavors you’ll want to recreate come November. Practicing now means you’ll be ready to wow your guests when Thanksgiving arrives. Pie baking dishes also make thoughtful gifts for anyone who loves to bake or entertain. They’re a practical present for newlyweds, housewarmings, or anyone building a kitchen collection. The right dish can inspire creativity, turning a simple recipe into a showstopper. Gifting a pie dish, especially when paired with a handwritten recipe or a set of pie weights, is a personal gesture that encourages connection and tradition. And for those who appreciate contemporary design, there are many options that blend classic function with modern style—explore the latest in Modern Pie Dishes to find pieces that complement any kitchen décor.

When selecting a Thanksgiving pie baking dish, consider how you’ll use it beyond the holiday. Many dishes are versatile enough for quiches, tarts, or savory pot pies, making them a year-round staple. Look for features like easy-grip handles, nonstick interiors, or oven-to-table designs that make serving effortless. The weight and durability of a dish can also impact your experience, especially if you plan to transport your pie to a family gathering or potluck. A well-chosen pie dish becomes a trusted companion in the kitchen, helping you create memories with every bake. Whether you’re perfecting your grandmother’s recipe or experimenting with new flavors, the right dish supports your efforts and elevates your results, making every slice a celebration.

Top Picks For Thanksgiving Pie Baking Dishes


Best Sellers

Related Pages

Top Collections