Sandwich Sauces

Elevate your sandwich game with our diverse selection of delicious sauces that add a burst of flavor to every bite. Whether you're crafting a classic club, a hearty sub, or a gourmet panini, the right sauce can transform your creation into a culinary masterpiece. Explore an array of options that cater to every taste preference, from tangy and spicy to creamy and savory. Perfect for both casual lunches and sophisticated gatherings, these sandwich sauces are the secret ingredient to making your meals unforgettable. Discover the perfect match for your next sandwich adventure and let your taste buds relish in the delightful combinations.

Sort by:
  • Sur La Table Dijon Mustard Pail
    $24.95
    (8)

    Once you try it , you will never buy anything else. Great on sandwiches, hot dogs, anything you put mustard on. This is it......Yet not overpowering! Brings whatever sandwich, salad dressing or marinade to perfection.

    Pros: taste, complex flavor, good for gifting

  • Pommery Meaux Grain Mustard in Stoneware Crock, 17.6 oz.
    $28.95
    (21)

    This is the first time that I've had this mustard & will use it in many dishes, sandwiches, salad dressings & marinades....Meaux Mustard is THE most delicious compliment to any sandwich! So delicious we even like to enjoy it STRAIGHT from the jar.

    Pros: taste, versatility, quality

  • Sur La Table Classic Pizza Sauce
    $16.95

    Pizza night is sure to be a success with this blend of fresh tomatoes, olive oil and Italian herbs and spices. Simply cover pizza dough with this sauce and top with anything from fresh peppers and mushrooms to soppressata and goat cheese.

  • Les Moulins Mahjoub Traditional Harissa Spread
    $16.95
    (11)

    A spicy, medium-heat spread characterized by its grainy consistency and slightly smoked flavor. Excellent as a dip for fresh-baked bread or to add a unique zing to sauces. Imported from Tunisia.

    Pros: versatility, taste, spicy

  • Sur La Table Hot Pepper Bacon Jam
    $12.95
    (2)

    Roasted red bell pepper puree, jalapeño peppers and real bacon combine to create an addictive jam. For a quick appetizer, pour over cream cheese and serve with crackers. Use straight out of the jar as a dip. Pairs perfectly with strong cheeses. Delicious...

    Pros: compliments, well received, delicious

  • Sur La Table Salted Caramel Sauce
    $14.95

    Sweet, slightly salty and lusciously smooth. All good pastry chefs know a hint of salt accentuates the sweetness of any dessert and this was the idea behind our delicious and delightful Salted Caramel Sauce. Use this versatile sweet and salty caramel...

  • Sur La Table Spicy Pizza Sauce
    $10.99

    A delicious shortcut for homemade pizza night, our spicy pizza sauce is made with vine-ripened fresh tomatoes, basil and crushed red pepper flakes for a bit of heat. Try it with vegetarian toppings like eggplant, peppers and more, or try it with sausage...

  • La Favorita Genovese Pesto
    $16.95
    (3)

    The perfect blend of olive oil, cashews, pine nuts and basil from Liguria, this pesto embodies the full flavor of Italy. Add to pasta, pizza, sandwiches, scrambled eggs or spread atop goat cheese on a crostini to create a fancy appetizer.

    Located in the...

    Pros: basil pesto quality, taste

Sandwich Sauces

A great sandwich is more than just bread and fillings—it’s the sauces for sandwiches that bring everything together, transforming a simple lunch into something memorable. Whether you’re layering smoky turkey on a crusty baguette, stacking juicy tomatoes with creamy mozzarella, or assembling a classic grilled cheese, the right sauce can elevate every bite. From zesty aiolis and tangy mustards to herby pestos and rich, savory spreads, these condiments add depth, balance, and personality to your favorite creations. As summer unfolds and outdoor gatherings become the norm, having a selection of sandwich sauces on hand makes it easy to customize meals for everyone at the table. Imagine a backyard picnic where burgers, wraps, and veggie sandwiches are all improved by a drizzle of bright, flavorful sauce—each guest can make their meal their own, and even the simplest ingredients feel special.

When choosing sauces for sandwiches, consider the flavors and textures you love most. A smooth, creamy spread pairs beautifully with crisp vegetables, while bold, spicy sauces can cut through the richness of roasted meats or cheeses. If you enjoy experimenting in the kitchen, keep a few versatile options in your pantry or fridge—something tangy for cutting through fattier fillings, something sweet for pairing with salty or smoky flavors, and perhaps an herby or garlicky blend for a fresh finish. These sauces are not only practical for everyday lunches but also make thoughtful gifts for food lovers, home cooks, or anyone who loves to entertain. Tuck a selection into a housewarming basket, or bring a few to a summer barbecue as a host gift; they’re sure to spark conversation and inspire creativity in the kitchen. For those who enjoy exploring new flavors, browsing our collection of Cooking Sauces can open up even more possibilities, from international favorites to unique small-batch blends.

Incorporating sauces for sandwiches into your routine is an easy way to refresh your meals without much effort. They’re perfect for busy weekdays, when you want to add excitement to a packed lunch, or for leisurely weekends spent building the ultimate club sandwich or panini. Many sauces double as dips, marinades, or dressings, making them a versatile addition to any kitchen. As you explore new combinations, you’ll discover how a spoonful of the right sauce can turn leftovers into a crave-worthy meal or help you make the most of seasonal produce. Whether you’re a seasoned cook or just starting to experiment with homemade sandwiches, having a range of flavorful sauces on hand ensures that every meal feels a little more special, no matter the occasion.

Top Picks For Sandwich Sauces


Best Sellers

Related Pages

  •
    Gift Sauces

    "So good, I ordered several as holiday gifts"

  •
    Unique Sauces

    "This sauce is so yummy! I can't wait to use it on a pizza one day"

  •
    Sauce Seasonings

    "I used this for dipping oil, with the herb seasoning packet I also purchased from Sur La Table"

  •
    Salad Condiments

    "needed a mister to make my homemade salad dressing in. It works well"

  •
    Sweet Sauce

    "The consistency is like a moderately thick syrup with the hint of sweet balanced by the beauty of the balsamic. Used on salad, berries, and cheese enhances the taste of every food and makes your mouth water. 12 year aged... a wonderful addition to any meal"

Top Collections